Enemies Among Us is one of the most pivotal Act 1 main quests in Dragon Age 2, delving into the growing tension between mages and templars in Kirkwall. Hawke is drawn into the mystery after meeting Macha, a woman searching for her missing brother Keran who recently joined the Templar Order. Investigating his disappearance uncovers a dangerous conspiracy involving demon possession and rogue blood mages.

Starting the Quest and Investigating the Gallows

To initiate the quest, head to the Chantry courtyard in Hightown during the day after completing the quest Tranquility. Speak with Macha to learn about Keran's troubling disappearance and agree to look into the matter. Afterward, travel to the Gallows Courtyard to question Keran's fellow recruits about his recent behavior.

The recruits will reluctantly point you toward Wilmod, another recruit stationed at a nearby camp. Upon arriving at Wilmod's Camp, you will encounter Knight-Captain Cullen during a confrontation. A battle immediately triggers as Wilmod gives in to demonic possession, spawning abominations and a Rage Demon.

Tracing the Blood Mage Conspiracy

Following the fight at Wilmod's Camp, your investigation leads to The Blooming Rose brothel in Lowtown. Inside, speak with Idunna to uncover her connection to the rogue templars. Be cautious during this dialogue, as Idunna attempts to use blood magic to mind-control Hawke during the interrogation.

If you bring a mage companion like Anders or Merrill, they can help disrupt the spell and save Hawke. After confronting Idunna, search her belongings to obtain the location of the blood mage hideout hidden within Darktown. This underground sanctuary serves as the central hub for the corrupting ritual.

Clearing the Sanctuary and Rescuing Keran

In the Darktown hideout, navigate through waves of corpses, skeletons, and hostile mages until you reach the inner chamber. You will face Tarhone, a powerful blood mage who summons otherworldly creatures to stop your party. Focus your attacks on controlling the add spawns while using area-of-effect spells to clear the room efficiently.

Once Tarhone is defeated, you will locate Keran alive in the hideout. You can inspect him or let Anders or Merrill examine him to determine if he has been possessed by a demon. This decision plays a crucial role in deciding Keran's fate when reporting back to Knight-Captain Cullen.

Deciding Keran's Fate and Quest Consequences

Return to the Gallows Courtyard to present your findings to Cullen and conclude the mission. You can either vouch for Keran's innocence or declare him a threat due to potential lingering demonic influence. Convincing Cullen that Keran is safe allows him to remain a templar, which later unlocks the Act 2 quest How to Frame a Templar.

Alternatively, claiming Keran is possessed results in his dismissal from the Order, leading to the quest A Debt in the Family in Act 2 instead. Both outcomes offer unique narrative paths, making your choices in this quest impactful for Hawke's journey through Kirkwall.